Political Instability in France: How A System Built to Prevent Chaos Has Collapsed Into It

author
Dr. Louis Perron
blog post louis

In a bit more than a year, France has gone through three Prime Ministers. A journalist recently asked me why French politics has become so volatile, and while the short answer is simple, the longer explanation is the account about how a political system that was built to prevent chaos has collapsed into it.

How Macron Triggered the Current Crisis

The immediate cause of the current turmoil is President Emmanuel Macron’s decision in June of last year to dissolve the National Assembly and hold early elections. He made that call in the aftermath of the elections for the European Parliament. But the gamble on a snap election backfired: instead of strengthening his position, he lost his already-slim majority.

A Presidential System—But Only When Conditions Are Right

People often think of France as a classic presidential system. And indeed, the Fifth Republic was probably designed in 1958 to empower the president and avoid the constant instability of the preceding Fourth Republic.

But that only worked for as long as the president and the majority in parliament were of the same political family. In such a scenario, and that’s probably how the system was envisioned, the prime minister is essentially the president’s lieutenant, carrying out the presidential agenda.

However, when the majority in the National Assembly belongs to a different political camp than the president, the dynamics of French polity change. Power shifts away from the Elysée Palace and toward the National Assembly. The president remains influential—especially in foreign policy and defense—but the prime minister becomes the central domestic actor.

The French call this cohabitation, and it has happened several times.

Socialist President François Mitterrand was forced to coexist and govern with prime ministers from the right, at first with Jacques Chirac and then at a later stage with Édouard Balladur. When Chirac became president himself, and after another snap election that backfired, Chirac had to govern for a number of years with Socialist Prime Minister Lionel Jospin.

Those periods were at times conflict-ridden, but the system withstood those incidents of cohabitation because there was still a majority in parliament—just not the president’s.

Why This Time Is Different

Today’s crisis is different: there is no majority in parliament. In other words, the current challenges are not because of cohabitation, but because of fragmentation. Following the snap election last year, no political bloc commands a majority. Not Macron’s centrists, not the right, the far right, nor the left. In fact, the left alliance consisting of Socialists, Greens, and the far left won a plurality of the seats, but still fell short of majority.

What has happened ever since the snap election is that Macron has been maneuvering to prevent a government from the left to take its seat. His strategy was to assemble a centrist–center-right coalition supplemented with just enough Socialist votes to scrape together a majority.

But the arithmetic is unforgiving:

– Give the Socialists what they want (taxing the rich, undoing the pension reform), and you lose the right.

– Give the right what they want, and the Socialists walk away (and vote with the rest of the left and the far right to overthrow the government).

Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu and before him Michel Barnier and François Bayrou are all facing the same impossible equation.

All this is unfolding while France is facing an ever-bigger deficit. It leaves voters with the impression that the elite can’t get its act together and that the system is not working, which in turn is fueling populism on the right and of the left of the political spectrum.

Is There a Way Out?

If I were to advise Macron, I would propose a government of national unity, something like Switzerland’s all-party system. Instead of being blackmailed by the parties, the president could hand the ball back to them and force them to take responsibility.

Alternatively, France could adopt a government of technocrats, as Italy has done during its own deadlocks, bringing in experts instead of partisan ministers.

But both solutions are uncharacteristic of French political culture and would require a significant leap into untested territory. I think that they are therefore unlikely to happen. The most likely outcome is probably another snap election rather sooner than later.

It is, however, almost ironic that what is happening now is strikingly reminiscent of the Fourth Republic. It was a time when fragmented parties constantly negotiated unstable coalitions and governments fell regularly. The constitution of the Fifth Republic was crafted specifically to avoid that fate. Yet, paradoxically, France seems to have drifted back into precisely the kind of parliamentary chaos it sought to escape decades ago.

PS: Check out my channel on YouTube where the latest video is also on the current political turmoil in France.

Sign up for my newsletter, The Campaign Doctor™, and get regular insights and takeaways on elections.

As a free gift, I'll send you my booklet "Seven Hot Tips to Win Elections in 2026"